In the summer of 2023, Manchester United made headlines when they parted ways with veteran goalkeeper David De Gea – who had spent 12 years at the club – and brought in Andre Onana from Inter Milan for nearly £50 million. This decision immediately sparked debates among experts and fans alike.
1. Why MU chose Onana over De Gea
In his final years at Old Trafford, De Gea was often criticized for his limited ball-playing ability, which did not suit Erik ten Hag’s modern football philosophy – a style built on control and playing out from the back. Onana, on the other hand, is well known for his distribution, composure on the ball, and experience in the Champions League.
2. What Onana brings to the team
Onana offers a noticeable difference in ball distribution. He frequently steps up to join the build-up, helping the defense relieve pressing pressure from opponents. The Cameroonian goalkeeper also possesses strong reflexes and was a key figure in Inter Milan’s run to the 2023 Champions League final.
3. Limitations and controversies
Despite high expectations, Onana made several errors in his early days at United, from risky decisions to conceding avoidable goals. This has raised the question: Was nearly £50 million worth sacrificing De Gea’s stability?
4. A broader perspective
In reality, United did not just spend money on a goalkeeper; they invested in a new style of play. Onana fits Ten Hag’s vision, but any transition takes time to prove its value. If he can adapt quickly and cut down on mistakes, this deal could become a positive turning point for the Red Devils.
Conclusion:
The question “Is Onana worth £50 million?” cannot yet be answered with certainty. What is clear, however, is that this transfer reflects MU’s determination to rebuild. Onana’s future at Old Trafford depends on whether he can turn pressure into motivation to prove himself – or end up being one of the club’s costly gambles.